Kevin,
I removed my stripes with a razorblade and then took off the residual sticker goo with acetone... LOTS of it! I wetsanded the hull with 1000grit then ran a buffer with a wool pad and polishing compound. She looked as good as new.
Paint vs. Vinyl Boot stripes, I would go with vinyl from Pro Stripe. If applied the correct way they should last 7-8 years and not a PITB to remove. If you want to do a tape stripe on your flybridge then that's move complicated because of the compound curve and getting the stripe to make the turn. There is also an issue with the front of the flybridge laying back at an angle. A 2" stripe layed at 45 degrees looks like a 1" stripe.
You're up in Vista I'm in Escondido... not too far. You can stop buy and check out what I did on Hamachi Girl and/or I could stop buy and help you out.
Allan
Allan C.
P.E.T.A MEMBER
Portagee Euthanizing Terrified Albacore
Hamachi Girl
1981 23' Albacore Special